Monday, October 24, 2022

The executioner and the soldier

 Maistre laughed at the claims that human beings are rational.

Look, he said, at how the public treats the public executioner and the soldier.

In those days, every city had a hangman. But that fellow was widely ostracized. People wouldn’t talk to him. They would snub his family.

The soldier home from the wars, on the other hand, was treated like a hero.

The difference, Maistre said, was that the executioner killed bad men, while the soldier killed honorable men who were fighting for their country and innocent civilians.

Men don’t live by reason, at least in Maistre’s telling.

• Isaiah Berlin, Freedom and Its Betrayal; Princeton University Press, 2002.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Georgia Piedmont, late autumn

  The latest cold front looks like it might stay a while. It chased off the rain with 25-mph winds. Temperatures dropped into the 30s. We co...