Saturday, July 26, 2025

He wrote remarks

 One of the things I like about Wittgenstein was that his writings are in the form of remarks. He wrote remarks.

That sounds odd because we don’t think of remarks as a literary form, although we occasionally come close when talking about aphorisms. But an aphorism seems to me to be a polished thing, while a remark is a quick observation made in the heat of an investigation.

I’ll admit that I’ve never heard a crowd clamoring for the recognition of the remark as a literary form. But I did run across this from W.H. Auden:

 

A poem must be a closed system, but there is something, in my opinion, lifeless, even false, in systematic criticism. In going over my critical pieces, I have reduced them, when possible, to sets of notes because, as a reader, I prefer a critic’s notebooks to his treatises.

 

It’s remarkable to me that Auden rewrote critical essays into the form of “sets of notes,” which I’d call remarks. I think it was a good call. But I think the remark is a literary form.

• Source: W.H. Auden, The Dyer’s Hand; New York: Vintage International, 1989, p. xii. For an earlier note on the same idea, see “The remark as a literary form,” July 4, 2022.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Hints on curtain calls

 Edward Hoagland, the writer and naturalist, died at 93. At 76, he wrote about death and how he imagined he’d go about dying. The gist of it...