Ludwig Wittgenstein, who watched Europe descend into insanity before World War II, wrote this:
When you can’t unravel a tangle, the most sensible thing is for you to recognize this; and the most honorable thing, to admit it. …
What you ought to do to remedy the evil is not clear. What you must not do is clear in particular cases.
My ellipsis marks the spot of a note in parentheses that makes it clear he was talking about antisemitism. But I think his observation is generally true of all tangles in the social fabric, including antisemitism, racism, xenophobia and the kind of greed that allows us to exploit neighbors and destroy the natural world while pretending our enterprise is a virtue.
The remedy for all these tangles is not clear, at least not to me. But I think Wittgenstein was right: On a case-by-case basis in our dealings with people, it’s usually clear what not to do.
When doctors are trained, they learn the first rule is to do no harm.
It’s not a bad rule for citizens.
• Source: Ludwig Wittgenstein, Culture and Value; The University of Chicago Press, 1984, p. 74.
No comments:
Post a Comment