These lines from Aldo Leopold haunt me:
We abuse land because we regard it as a commodity belonging to us. When we see land as a community to which we belong, we may begin to use it with love and respect.
I suspect that if my generation will be remembered for anything, it will be as witnesses of unfathomable destruction of the natural world. I think most of the debate about our place in history will rely on words like “complicit.”
I grew up among people who believed the right to private property to be inalienable. Perhaps I still believe that. But I think our ideas are fatally flawed.
The kind of land ownership we take for granted was banned when Georgia became a colony in 1733. Immigrants were assigned land — a 60-by-90 lot in Savannah, a 5-acre garden on the edge of town and a 45-acre farm in the country. But the land was assigned to them. The colonists could not sell or mortgage it.
The folks I grew with would say that’s not ownership. They would say the land didn’t really belong to the colonists.
A loose political coalition called the Malcontents lobbied relentlessly against the foundations of the colony, established by a board of trustees in London as a charity to help those in debt. The Malcontents wanted free enterprise. They wanted fee-simple ownership of land and they wanted enslaved people to work it. By 1750, they had their way.
Just about everybody recognizes that the idea of owning people poisoned this country in ways that still scar it today. But I, for one, am late to game at looking at our ideas about owning land and the damage they’ve done.
I’m still trying to work out the logic.
Under the law, a citizen has the right to own a dog. But if you abuse the dog — chain it outside with no water or food, say — you can end up in jail. I’ve seen some tragic cases in the news. Public sentiment is strong for locking up the guilty.
What if a citizen doesn’t harm an individual animal but bulldozes a habitat for a new development? Does he get an award from the chamber of commerce?
The concept of ownership usually has a concept of stewardship inside. It’s as if we have a set of nesting dolls, and one is missing.
Or, as Leopold put it, we have to stop thinking that the decent use of land is solely an economic problem.
• Source: Aldo Leopold, A Sand County Almanac; New York: Ballentine Books, 1982, pp. xviii and 262.
No comments:
Post a Comment