Friday, November 20, 2026

Providence Canyon

 Providence Canyon is a series of canyons in the southern half of Georgia near the Alabama line. The walls are 150 feet tall in places, and I tried to get my eyes to see evidence of the difference geologic periods.

This part of the world was a seabed 60 million years ago. The layers of sediment on the canyon walls accreted over millions of years, including the age of dinosaurs.

The canyon looks like the canyons you see in the West. Out there, it takes a stream millions of years to carve a canyon.

But Providence Canyon was created in historical times. 

In the early 1800s, European settlers arrived, and some started plowing in bad places. They ignored warning signs they were on land that had thin topsoil and was easily eroded. By the 1850s people were reporting gullies 3 to 5 feet deep.

Georgia gets plenty of rainfall. Water rushing down gullies through soft, crumbly rock does quick work. The canyon walls are still eroding. Some of the pinnacles you see can collapse in a storm.

It’s hard to fathom — how land that formed over eons can be damaged so profoundly and so quickly by human beings using modest technology, a mule-drawn plow.

If you’re curious about the name: Providence Methodist Church started in 1832 in a log structure and moved into a sawn-timber building in 1859. The new church still stands and has a hip roof, which you don’t often see on churches in the rural South.

The church and cemetery are just north of the rim.

Thursday, November 19, 2026

An anthologist talks about choices

 I’m interested in collecting and collections. I’m also interested by the notion of a canon, a shared collection of, say, literature, art or music.

David Lehman, who edited The Oxford Book of American Poetry, has a lovely essay in The Hudson Review about what a person is doing when making an anthology.

Lehman’s collection is 20 years old. It replaced an edition that was 30.

Lehman’s anthology is broader: It includes 210 poets, where the older edition had 78. He makes the case for minor poets and one-shot wonders. He says that each new anthology is a chance to amend a reputation.

He talks about why a person chooses one poem and not another:

 

An insistent pleasure-principle tops my criteria. “Pleasure is by no means an infallible critical guide, but it is the least fallible,” W. H. Auden observed.

 

We humans collect things. Sometimes these things please us so much that we’re surprised by the pleasure, and we want to share. Not all human traits are wonderful, but this one is.

• David Lehman, “Notes on Making a Canonical Anthology: The Oxford Book of American Poetry”; The Hudson Review, Autumn, 2026. It’s here:

https://hudsonreview.com/2026/10/notes-on-making-a-canonical-anthology-the-oxford-book-of-american-poetry/

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Owning a flawed idea

 These lines from Aldo Leopold haunt me:

We abuse land because we regard it as a commodity belonging to us. When we see land as a community to which we belong, we may begin to use it with love and respect. 

 

I suspect that if my generation will be remembered for anything, it will be as witnesses of unfathomable destruction of the natural world. I think most of the debate about our place in history will rely on words like “complicit.”

I grew up among people who believed the right to private property to be inalienable. Perhaps I still believe that. But I think our ideas are fatally flawed.

The kind of land ownership we take for granted was banned when Georgia became a colony in 1733. Immigrants were assigned land — a 60-by-90 lot in Savannah, a 5-acre garden on the edge of town and a 45-acre farm in the country. But the land was assigned to them. The colonists could not sell or mortgage it.

The folks I grew with would say that’s not ownership. They would say the land didn’t really belong to the colonists.

A loose political coalition called the Malcontents lobbied relentlessly against the foundations of the colony, established by a board of trustees in London as a charity to help those in debt. The Malcontents wanted free enterprise. They wanted fee-simple ownership of land and they wanted enslaved people to work it. By 1750, they had their way.

Just about everybody recognizes that the idea of owning people poisoned this country in ways that still scar it today. But I, for one, am late to game at looking at our ideas about owning land and the damage they’ve done.

I’m still trying to work out the logic.

Under the law, a citizen has the right to own a dog. But if you abuse the dog — chain it outside with no water or food, say — you can end up in jail. I’ve seen some tragic cases in the news. Public sentiment is strong for locking up the guilty.

What if a citizen doesn’t harm an individual animal but bulldozes a habitat for a new development? Does he get an award from the chamber of commerce?

The concept of ownership usually has a concept of stewardship inside. It’s as if we have a set of nesting dolls, and one is missing.

Or, as Leopold put it, we have to stop thinking that the decent use of land is solely an economic problem.

• Source: Aldo Leopold, A Sand County Almanac; New York: Ballentine Books, 1982, pp. xviii and 262.

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

The Debatable Land

 I’m interested in the notion of place, particularly as it applies to this new place I call home. I was astonished to find that it was briefly the Margravate of Azilia.

For almost 200 years, Georgia was known as the Debatable Land, the contested are between the British in Virginia and the Spanish in Florida. Both sides and their Native American allies raided each other. The massacres in the backwoods went on until economics changed the picture.

The British colonies in the New World were not economically equal. Some were a drain on crown and Parliament. But the colonies in the Caribbean — islands of sugarcane fields tended by enslaved workers — produced fabulous wealth.

Carolina was chartered in 1633, and the plantations in what is now South Carolina rivaled those in the Caribbean.

With serious money involved, the backwoods bushwhacking and raiding was viewed as a threat to wealth, which couldn’t be tolerated. People looked at the Debatable Land and saw the need for a militarized buffer zone.

In 1717, Sir Robert Montgomery proposed the margrave, a privately owned province, to Carolina’s governing board. The board approved with the understanding that Montgomery would pay to build and fortify it.

London was appalled and ruled that the board had overstepped its authority. No new provinces would be created in North America without approval from London.

The argument involved people with money, and the dustup was significant enough that London agreed to build Fort King George on the mainland opposite Sapelo Island.

It’s now a historic site in Darien. But if you were a British soldier in the 1720s, it was the end of the world. The place was so remote it was hard to supply, meaning it was famous for starvation and disease. When the fort mysteriously caught fire, the officers noticed that the enlisted men didn’t exactly rush to put out the flames.

I like being a resident of the Debatable Land. I like places that have a long history of uncertainty about who’s in charge.

• Source: Christopher C. Meyers and David Williams, Georgia: A Brief History; Macon, Ga.: Mercer University Press, 2023, p. 12.

Monday, November 16, 2026

First freeze

 I put the first fire in our fireplace on Nov. 14.

The first freeze was early on Nov. 15.

It’s about five weeks until the Winter Solstice. I’ve been thinking that this is a short season for naturalists, kind of like Advent in the Christian calendar. While liturgical Christians are looking forward to something, I’m winding down.

Sunday, November 15, 2026

Relevance

 One of the most interesting comments on the election in Georgia came from one of the most conservative members of the General Assembly. State Rep. Steven Sainz, R-St. Marys, said he’d talked with a manager of a grocery chain that tracks the percentage of customers who must put items back because they can’t pay the entire bill. The usual rate of 3 percent had jumped to 14.

I think Sainz has his finger on a good index of relevance. The party that wants to be considered relevant will pay attention to that number and to other numbers that suggest that people are sliding into the kind of poverty that involves hunger.

I’d say a party that can’t pause its culture wars agenda long enough to address that problem is going to be irrelevant overnight.

Saturday, November 14, 2026

Helping and pretending to help

 Our county commissioners passed an ordinance that prohibits homeless people from camping in public places.

It was so bad it was almost funny.

Dekalb County is not a place that hates poor people. Most people are not philosophically opposed to spending public money for the common good. Most do not think that our social problems can be solved by more aggressive policing.

However, the problems involving people with mental illnesses and drug addictions are real. Constituents complained, and so the commissioners had to appear to be doing something.

The new law authorizes police officers to arrest people who camp on sidewalks, parking lots and other public places. But before the officers make an arrest, they must follow a long checklist. Was the person accused of illegal camping aware of the law? Had he been previously warned?  Was the person informed of resources available to the homeless? It’s a long list.

The law in unenforceable. I can say that with confidence because I spent decades watching communities try and fail to address similar problems in Texas.

The community that did the best work was Galveston. It followed the advice of my friend Ted Hanley, executive director of The Jesse Tree, a volunteer organization.

The program worked because it acknowledged that people who are homeless generally have more than one problem. Most have problems with mental health and addiction. But many also have chronic problems, such as diabetes and hypertension. They collapse in public places and end up in ambulances and emergency rooms.

Ted convinced the community that it could save money on police time, ambulance runs and emergency-room visits if it invested in prevention.

It’s a long story, but the breakthrough was a universal application form. The Jesse Tree offered hot meals and canned foods. When homeless people came, volunteers helped them fill out a form that all social service agencies would accept. Volunteers could steer vulnerable people — people who weren’t good at taking care of themselves — toward help.

This was incremental improvement, rather than a solution. But things were observably — even measurably — better. (Police calls and emergency room visits are measurable expenses.)

Perhaps the biggest change was in the people who felt a responsibility to help.

When I’m accosted by a person asking for money, I usually see a problem, rather than a person. Should I give this person a couple of bucks for food? Or am I just contributing to an addiction?

The Jesse Tree taught its volunteers to look at the individual. If you didn’t know the person asking for money, perhaps you’d give him the benefit of the doubt and give him some money. But if the same person stood on the same corner with the same hard-luck story for years, you probably should keep the money in your pocket.

Sometimes, I’d get a ride from someone and see a box with bottled water, packages of nuts, bananas and other healthy snacks on the seat. I took it as a small bit of evidence of change, good change.

Friday, November 13, 2026

Glimpse of a forest dweller

 Because we had an early appointment and needed to walk the dog, we got to the woods before sunup. In the headlights, we saw a man breaking camp. He was wearing two coats and two hats. Everything he owned was going into a cart.

I’ve made a note of many species of creatures we have seen in the woods. I should have included Homo sapiens.

Thursday, November 12, 2026

The special calling

 Scott Russell Sanders says the Midwest was the most fertile place in the United States. Of all the places where a new Garden of Eden might have bloomed in North America, the Midwest was the favored spot.

Instead, what people have witnessed — and what writers have written about — is the damage done to the land. People also discovered that damage to habitats damages inhabitants. Sanders said:

 

Becoming aware of the richness in long-settled, cultivated, often battered and abandoned country is the special calling of Midwestern writers.

 

Sanders’s argument is rooted in two observations by Alexis de Tocqueville, who recorded his impressions of America in 1831-2.

First, Europeans talked of the wilds of America, but the Americans never did. Americans saw a rich land, richer than the Promised Land, and they wanted to master it, subjugate it, dominate it. For Americans, awe and respect weren’t appropriate responses.

Second, for all their talk about freedom of expression, there was little in America. The social pressure to conform was extreme. Expression of opinion amounted to self-congratulatory effusions about community progress. Following the interests of the wealthy, Americans developed aggressively and preserved reluctantly. Collectively, it took a long time to wake up to the damage: to the land, to communities, to individuals.

 

Because of its resources and history, and in spite of its homegrown critics, the Midwest would eventually become in our mythology something of an agrarian theme park, a repository of the values that Americans wish to preserve but not live by: hard work, honesty, frugality, simplicity, integrity, neighborliness, egalitarianism, politeness, and decency. There is enough truth in that list of Heartland virtues for the impression to have survived into our own time.

 

As soon as I open my mouth, people know where I’m from. I’ve never been mistaken for a Midwesterner.

Sanders’s essay made me see how little I know little about the Midwest.

I wondered how many of those American values — hard work, honesty, frugality and the rest — people would associate with my part of the world.

• Source: Scott Russell Sanders, Writing from the Center; Bloomington: University of Indiana, 1997. “Imagining the Midwest” is on pp. 22-51. The quotations are on pp. 36 and 39.

Wednesday, November 11, 2026

Midwestern writers

 I’m interested in the idea of place, and I’m interested in the way Scott Russell Sanders thinks about it. The notion of place is influenced by writers, and Sanders’s essay “Imagining the Midwest” is a survey of the region’s literature.

Sanders contends that writers from New England and the South tend to stay put, while writers from the Midwest tend to write in exile. Mark Twain wrote about Missouri and the Mississippi from Connecticut. Willa Cather wrote about Nebraska from New York. Ernest Hemingway wrote about Michigan from Paris. Sanders said:

 

Midwestern writers have not been so much lured elsewhere, I suspect, as driven out, by a combination of puritanical religion, utilitarian economics, and anti-intellectualism.

 

That idea is intriguing, but he added this:

.

Nowhere was that religion harsher, fiercer, more hostile to sensuality or speculation than in the Midwest — or at least so it has seemed to our writers.

 

I’d say the Midwestern writers might have been astonished at the fierceness of religion in the South, where the practice of handling rattlesnakes as a test of faith is almost extinct. And while Babbitt might have the brand for anti-intellectualism, it was Tennessee that gave us the Snopes monkey trial and Texas that has been legislating what can’t be taught in history class. I’m not an expert, but if you’re looking for a decades-long record of attacks on academic freedom at universities, can anyone really beat the Texas Legislature?

I think that some of the forces that shaped Midwestern writers also are known in other parts of the country. But that’s just a disagreement about one point in a thought-provoking essay.

Sanders’s essays are always thought-provoking. I’m trying to read just about everything this Midwestern writer has written.

• Source: Scott Russell Sanders, Writing from the Center; Bloomington: University of Indiana, 1997. “Imagining the Midwest” is on pp. 22-51. The quotations are on p. 25.

Tuesday, November 10, 2026

Off the trail

 The Wise Woman was ever so tactful, but she wanted to know whether I had lost the trail.

The leaves have fallen so quickly it’s sometimes hard to know. The leaves are ankle deep on the forest floor. I know there’s a trail of packed earth somewhere out there, but the thick blanket covers everything.

While we were searching, we saw a buck, maybe 10 points, who seemed to be searching too. As we watched, a doe appeared — almost as if by magician’s trick — and the two went on their way.

We found the trail and went on ours.

Monday, November 9, 2026

Saluting a purged admiral

 One of the most interesting new members of Congress is Nancy Lacore of South Carolina, a retired rear admiral who was ousted in the purge of senior commanders by the secretary of defense, Pete Hegseth. The U.S. military is in a mess because Hegseth is a political ideologue — a yes man, rather than a manager and leader. Admiral Lacore strikes me as a person who knows how to clean up a mess.

I’ve complained about the purge of admirals and generals before. In the 1930s, Stalin purged the Red Army of professional commanders, replacing them with politically reliable officers. The Nazis took note. Although Germany was a much smaller country, it pushed the Soviet military around in the early part of the war. Stalin’s political appointments were inept.

In my view, no one has done more to weaken the U.S. military than Hegseth. The process for selecting the nation’s top commanders is selective and competitive. Hegseth forced excellent officers out. He got rid of women, minorities and people with advanced educational credentials.

He seems to have problems with people who can understand things he can’t. The purge was a terrible idea, but the Pentagon, under Hegseth, also is having difficulty managing contracts and overseeing the development of new weapons.

After being fired by Hegseth, Lacore, a Democrat, won a congressional seat in that had been heavily Republican. A lot of people who are interested in the Armed Forces think the Pentagon could do better. No one knows better than Admiral Lacore.

• For an earlier note complaining about the removal of top generals and admirals, see “Everyone knew it was a bad war,” April 16, 2026. It’s here:

https://hebertaylor.blogspot.com/2026/04/everyone-knew-it-was-bad-war.html

Sunday, November 8, 2026

Coyotes

 Darwin said that when we’re talking about the survival of the fittest, we’re not talking about the strongest or most intelligent but about those that can adapt to change.

The coyote is an adaptable animal. As the human population has increased, coyotes have spread from the Southwest across the United States and Canada. Coyotes prevailed despite efforts to exterminate them.

You’d think that wolves, being bigger and stronger, would have fared better. But animals don’t just adapt to their environment. They also adapt within groups — within social structures.

Wolves have always been animals of the pack. They live within a rigid social structure. Coyotes are more flexible. They live alone, in pairs, in small groups and in packs.

I would love to better understand how that’s possible — how one species can incorporate greater flexibility in its social life.

I’d like to know whether human beings could do something similar — whether we could reorganize our social structures to do less damage to the environment, the habit we live in and depend on.

I’m reading Dan Flores’s Coyote America with pleasure. Flores loves coyotes as much as I do, although we see them from different points of view. Flores is interested in humanity’s tendency to see itself in the coyote, as I’ve just done with that crack about whether we humans could be as flexible as coyotes.

Flores’s thinking is heavy on history, anthropology and folklore. It’s fascinating, but I’m more interested in the biology — how it’s possible that one species of social animals can adapt when another cannot.

• Source and note: Dan Flores, Coyote America; New York: Basic Books, 2026. And thanks, Christopher, for the recommendation.

Saturday, November 7, 2026

The news from Wally

 In 1565, the Spanish were on the coast of what’s now Georgia. They called the place Guale, which later generations of English speakers would pronounce “Wally.”

The place was named for a leader of the Guale people, who were distinct from the Timucua and Apalachee. Spanish Franciscans set up missions.

In 1597, a group of Guale people began killing priests. The match that lit the fire was a dispute over whether a local leader named Juanillo could take a second wife. But this was not a personal quarrel. It was an uprising, a broad dispute about who was going to make the rules, who was in charge. It was an attempt by one group to throw off the influence — the dominance — of another.

The Spanish entrepreneurs of the day were frank about their plans to exploit people for their labor and wealth. It was an age in which Spanish entrepreneurs kidnapped and enslaved native people to work on the sugar plantations in the Caribbean.

Some of the Franciscan fathers were the most outspoken critics of slavery and exploitation. Others went along with the crowd.

All this ancient history is not quite dead.

The Georgia Martyrs are a topic of discussion today Georgia. In 2025, Pope Francis authorized the bureau that examines questions of beatification and sanctification to recognize five priests as martyrs, murdered “in hatred of the faith.” At the cathedral in Savanah last weekend, there was a celebration of the martyrs. It was statewide news.

Two people can witness the same incident and come to different conclusions. That’s true of the events we witness today and true of the events of the past.

I don’t whether I have more sympathy for the massacrers or the massacred. I grieve for both.

Friday, November 6, 2026

In Georgia, 500 years ago

 The first Europeans in what is now Georgia were slave traders led by Lucas Vázquez de Ayllón.

The Spanish in the Caribbean had enslaved Africans but saw even greater possibilities in enslaving the natives of the New World. The plantations on Hispaniola and Cuba needed workers, and the Europeans thought of enslaving, rather than recruiting and paying. Georgia was closer than Africa. It was a shorter supply chain.

In 1526, Ayllón, sailing from Hispaniola with six ships and 600 people, tried to set up a settlement called San Miguel de Gualdape. Historians think it was on Sapelo Sound, between Savannah and Brunswick.

Among the 600 were enslaved Africans. Georgia historians say this is the first recorded instance of enslaved Africans arriving in what is now the United States.

The venture lasted six weeks. The Africans revolted. Native Americans attacked. Supplies ran out. Disease ravaged the Europeans, killing many, including Ayllón. His surviving lieutenants and business associates split into factions.

In November 1526, the colony broke up. Historians say 150 of the 600 made it back to Hispaniola.

I’ve heard people talk about American Exceptionalism all my life. I always wonder whether these folks read much history.

American Exceptionalism stories tend to sound like Disney movies. This story is closer to a Cormac McCarthy novel.

• Source: Christopher C. Meyers and David Williams, Georgia: A Brief History; Macon, Ga.: Mercer University Press, 2023, pp. 4-5. Usage of the name of Lucas Vázquez de Ayllón varies, but I mostly found Ayllón.

Thursday, November 5, 2026

Politics and purity

 One of the most intriguing political stories in Georgia was about a fight that involved no Democrats.

All the combatants were Republicans. The case went to the state supreme court.

The question was: Who can be a member of the party?

A handful of candidates in a rural county contended that primary voters should decide.

But the county’s Republican Party Committee declared it had the right to screen candidates and reject those who were not conservative enough.

The supreme court followed the law and allowed primary voters to decide.

The case is funny because this much is obvious: If you wanted to lose an election, an efficient way to go about it would be to conduct an inquisition and exclude all those who were not doctrinally pure enough.

The case is sobering because the tendency toward puritanism runs in all political parties.

I would love to see people who care about the public’s business become more tolerant of diverse ideas so that they could form a broader consensus that is less tolerant of autocracy, corruption and cruelty.

Leaf fall

 The leaves started falling. Big news if you spend time in the woods. We had a blow, and it looked like a blizzard, the kind you see in the Upper Midwest, where the fall is so heavy it’s hard to see.

You still see a lot of green in the canopy. But a lot of the leaves that were changing colors are on the ground.

A lot, but not all. The reds you see in the forest are maples, sorrels and sumacs. The yellows are  hickories, persimmons, tulip trees, sweetgums and muscadines.

Wednesday, November 4, 2026

The election in Georgia

 People in Georgia were voting against something, rather than for something.

The divide in our state, like the divide in our country, is still there.

The spread in Georgia was 55-45 on almost every statewide race. (There were exceptions. The cosmos smiled on U.S. Sen. Jon Ossoff when it gave him his opponent, Mike Collins.) The election was not about the quality of the candidates. It was about a rogue president and the party that supported him.

Donald Trump asked voters to pretend that he was on the ballot. They didn’t need any encouragement.

Votes against are cast in anger. That’s a powerful force to get people to the polls, but it’s not sustainable. I hope the people who went to the polls will stick around and talk with each other and try to form a broader consensus, one that is less heartless toward those who are struggling to make a living wage and less forgiving of the corrupt.

I think that we could get close to 60-40 on those two points alone.

What happens when we write

 Souvankham Thammavongsa’s poem “Theory of Writing” compares the way we write to the way we learn to get to the number 4.

We learn 2 + 2 = 4 as kids. Later, we learn we can get to 4 by other ways, including algebra and geometry. In mathematics, our concept of what we’re doing gets larger as we progress. Perhaps, the poet suggests, something similar happens in writing.

 

Or maybe

It’s the ways in which you know how

To get to four that is the point of writing,

What you had to learn and build, the time it took

To hold open the possibility for yourself.

 

I like that line about holding open possibilities for yourself. I think writing is a way to learn — to become a larger person or a larger self in a way.

One of my prejudices is that most of what should count as writing occurs outside the business of composing sentences. Naturally, I like this poem.

• Source: Souvankham Thammavongsa’s “Theory of Writing” is at Poetry Daily:

https://poems.com/poem/theory-of-writing/

Thammavongsa was known as a poet before she published a collection of short stories. Stunned by the stories, I’ve been looking at her poems.

Tuesday, November 3, 2026

Stories about bewildering places

 I found Souvankham Thammavongsa’s How to Pronounce Knife, a collection of 14 short stories, and told myself I would enjoy one a night for two weeks.

But the stories were too good. I binged.

The stories are the kind I like. I can read one in 10 to 20 minutes. Each is so tight, so well made, it takes me to another world. To say they’re more rewarding than a 20-minute doomscroll doesn’t cover it.

Critics say Thammavongsa’s fiction is largely about Laotian refugees. She was born in a refugee camp in Thailand. Her parents crossed the Mekong River on a bamboo raft and made it to Canada.

The culture of the immigrant community is interesting, but the stories worked on me although I know little about Laos and its people. In the past few years, I’ve developed a sharper sense of what it’s like to live in a culture I don’t understand. I can understand how people who are having to adapt to a place they don’t understand can be uncertain, tentative, fearful.

I can see how, under pressure like that, adults sometimes act like children, and children have to act like adults.

Like the critics, I could see refugees in Thammavongsa’s stories. But I also could see myself.

• Source: Souvankham Thammavongsa, How to Pronounce Knife: New York: Back Bay Books, 2021. “Slingshot,” one of the stories in the collection, was picked up by Literary Hub after winning an O. Henry Award. It’s here:

https://lithub.com/slingshot/

Providence Canyon

 Providence Canyon is a series of canyons in the southern half of Georgia  near the Alabama line. The walls are 150 feet tall in places, and...